Jewish Pilots and Aircrews in the Battle of Britain
by Martin Sugarman
Introduction
The Allied
victory in The Battle of Britain was
a major turning point in World War Two.
The RAF, assisted by allied squadrons
from other nations, defeated the might
of a numerically far superior German
Luftwaffe in an air battle that lasted
(as officially defined) from July 10th to
October 31st 1940. As a result,
Hitler indefinitely postponed his planned
invasion of Britain because he and his
High Command understood that without
control of the air, German losses in
a seaborne and air invasion would have
meant unacceptably high casualties and
probable failure. This decision changed
the course of the war as Churchills’s “Few” held
back the tide so that Britain and its
allies could fight another day, and ultimately
win the struggle.
Participation
in the Battle of Britain by 2917 Allied
men of 71 squadrons or units, is defined
as being awarded the Battle of Britain
clasp ( worn on the 1939-45 Star – or
a silver gilt rosette if medal ribbons
only are worn) for having flown operationally
at least one authorised sortie with an
eligible unit of RAF Fighter Command,
Coastal Command or The Fleet Air Arm,
as a pilot or aircrew, between July 10th and
October 31st 1940. Of the
Allied participants (see table 1 for
the breakdown by nation), 544 were killed
and a further 794 were killed before
the war’s end .
Table 1: Breakdown by Nation |
| Great
Britain 2333 |
Czechoslovakia
88 |
France
13 |
Israel
1 |
| Poland
145 |
Australia
33 |
USA
11 |
Jamaica
1 |
| New
Zealand 126 |
Belgium
29 |
Ireland
10 |
Newfoundland
1 |
| Canada
98 |
South
Africa 25 |
Rhodesia
3 |
|
Using
Wynn’s data, the participation
of 34 definite Jewish airmen among “The
Few” is undoubtedly a large proportion
( 1.2% overall AND 1.1 % of the British
contingent ) compared to our numbers
in the general population of Britain,
which was, more or less as now, under
0.5%. This is all the more amazing, because
it is well known that most of the pilots
of the RAF at the time were pre war regular,
commissioned officers, or NCO’s
who had been aircraft apprentices, tradesmen
or non-pilot aircrew. As Jews have traditionally
rarely served in peace-time regular military
units to follow military careers, there
was and is, therefore, an already in
- built numerical bias against Jewish
numbers participating, before one even
attempts any analysis of any figures .
Flying
also were men of the Auxiliary Air Force
(AAF), the Royal Air Force Volunteer
Reserve (RAFVR) and University Air Squadrons – mobilised
shortly before the outbreak of war -
most of whom were spare time “weekend” fliers.
Again, few Jews in a predominantly working
class Jewish community at that time,
would have had the financial resources
to spend time learning to fly and undertaking
the expensive associated outlay, and
in addition, far fewer Jews were then
at University or the Public or Grammar
schools - unlike today - to take advantage
of the opportunities to fly even if they
could find the financial resources! A generally lower
level of formal education in the
sciences and mathematics in the Jewish
male population of enlistment age – owing
to the social conditions of the Jewish
community in Britain at the time – was
also an obstacle at interviews for the
RAF and RAFVR pilot training, which then
as now was more technologically demanding
than that required for entry into the
more ordinary trades of the Army and
Navy.
After
the Battle of Britain, when conscription
for all the armed forces really got under
way, thousands of Jews volunteered for
the RAF of course, and even those with
only very basic schooling could get onto
flying courses – if fit – so
long as they showed what was then called
an aptitude for learning. But in 1940,
the core of the RAF/RAFVR pilot elite
were basically highly educated middle
and upper middle class non-Jews – rather
like an exclusive club where everybody
knew everybody else - among whose ranks
Jews were disproportionately poorly represented.
The same can be said of Jewish representation
among the Australian, New Zealand, South
African and Canadian contingents.
Concerning
the large ( 5%) Polish contribution to
the allied pilots of the Battle, there
are other more sinister issues surrounding
the lower Jewish participation . Blatant
anti-Semitism can be added to the class
and education barriers explained above,
and made it particularly difficult for
Jews to get into the Polish Air Force,
or indeed obtain a commission in any
of the Polish Forces at that time. There
were of course Jewish officers as well
as thousands of Polish Jewish other ranks
in all the Polish Forces in 1939, but
promotion and entry to the more glamorous
positions such as flying was excessively
difficult for Polish Jews. Added to this,
we must be clear that many Polish Jews
hid their religious affiliation on enlistment
and changed their names aswell (both
because of Polish anti - Semitism – and
German, if they were captured!) so that
even searching through records of religious
denomination gives no real picture of
which Polish pilots were Jewish ; in
effect we will never know.
The
same may be said of the French (0.03%
of the Allied pilots), Czech (3%) and
Belgian (0.1%) Air Forces. But these
matters are difficult to prove, although
based on the well known general discrimination
that existed against Jews in most, if
not all, European countries, at all levels,
at that time and especially in the armed
forces.
Benjamin
Meirtchak’s seminal work on Polish
Jewish casualties is an amazing
contribution to our generally known high
level of Jewish participation in the
Polish forces – but it is also
just that – casualties only - and
so missing are all the Jewish Polish
pilots who had survived the Battle!
Given
all these factors it is even more remarkable
that so many Jewish airmen have been
identified by this research as being
in the front line of pilots and aircrew
in The Battle of Britain.
However,
the author’s research at the Imperial
War Museum Library in Lambeth uncovered
another and official study – “The
Battle of Britain Roll of Honour” published
by the Air Ministry in 1947, of those
killed during the Battle or died of wounds
later. Here were found more Jewish names
not published in Wynn’s book – either
because the Ministry used a different
definition of the time scale of the battle,
or a different definition of the term “operational
flight” or both - and includes
a large number of Bomber Command and
Coastal Command crew killed in action
but not included by Wynn in his study
. There is by no means universal agreement
among historians about either the
dates of the Battle or the squadrons
that took part! Again, this Air Ministry
list contains only those killed and so
excludes many more who took part, but
survived. If these Air Ministry names
are included then the percentage participation
of Jewish pilots and aircrew is greater
still. I discovered 10 Jewish men (plus
one – Bardega - not in either source)
out of an approximate 1000 names NOT
included by Wynn – ie a 1% participation – which,
as the figures above show , is a higher
than proportionate representation from
the British Jewish community by over
two times at least .The names of these
men I have indicated in the text as “Air
Ministry Roll”. Clearly the 46
Jewish Aircrew is still 1.2% of the new
3917 participants – again over
twice Jewish numbers in the general population
.
But
the problem is further compounded by
yet further lists in the two books, “Battle
over Britain” (F Mason, Alban Books,
London, 1969) - which states the period
of the Battle as having started on July
1st - and a further study “Battle
of Britain – The Forgotten Months,
November to December 1940” (J Foreman,
Air Research Publications, London, 1988);
he includes even more men, declaring
that the dates fixed by the RAF are incorrect
and are relevant only to those entitled
to wear the Battle of Britain clasp.
He argues, convincingly, that the scale
of the fighting on some days in December
and November 1940 exceeded some of the
worst days of the summer period.
Sources
The
main details came from scanning the almost
3000 biographical entries in the 595
pages of Wynn’s mammoth and ground
breaking research in his book (note 1).
These were all cross-checked for the
British personnel (2333) against the
Jewish Chaplains’ cards held at
the AJEX (Association of Jewish Ex-Servicemen
and Women) Military Museum in Hackney,
London, to reveal the British Jewish
Airmen who took part.
Having
extracted and typed alphabetically all
the non British men (full name and number)
by nationality (583 entries) I sent these
to RAF Innsworth where the
staff there untiringly – in three
major sessions – looked up the
religious denomination of each man .
It is somewhat disturbing, however, that
Innsworth’s records showed Nelson
(RCAF), van Mentz (SAAF) and Mamedoff
(USA) as Church of England when my searches
found conclusively that they were Jews
(see below). Also the Polish Jewish pilot
Klein) is shown as Catholic at Innsworth’s
records!
The
AJEX Jewish Chaplains’ cards added
further fine detail about the men, as
did information from Commonwealth War
Graves Commission registers, so brilliantly
available on their web site. The Jewish
Chronicle newspapers for the period 1940-46
were also closely scanned and revealed
further pilots names and personal details – as
the AJEX cards are not a complete record
of all the Jewish military personnel.
Information
on three of the Czech Jewish fliers came
from a web site math.fce.vutbr.cz/safarik/ACES1/ww2-commonwealth-jewish.html.
Henry
Morris’s books contain the
names of those killed which were extracted
from the Jewish Chaplains cards, but
also include those names submitted during
his survey, by surviving relatives of
those who were killed but who
did not necessarily have Chaplains cards
made out for them, for a variety of reasons.
Thus names have been found in Morris’s
books but who did NOT have cards – and
thus Morris’s books are often a
separate source of names of Jewish personnel
killed.
The
Jewish RAF participants in the Battle
of Britain
116515
Cyril Stanley “Bam” Bamberger
was
a Sergeant Pilot of Jewish origin (telephone
conversation with author), later Squadron
Leader, of 610 and 41 Squadrons. Born
in Port Sunlight on 4/5/19, he joined
the RAFVR in 1938 . He shot down two
Me109’s in his Spitfire (at Hawarden
and Hornchurch). Later (in 1941) he
volunteered for Malta and shot down
two Ju 87’s. He was commissioned
in 1942 and then volunteered for North
Africa and shot down another Ju 87
(Sicily) and damaged another ( Italy
- 1943) and was awarded the DFC on 28/9/43. In
Italy he shot down another 109 and
damaged another. On 3/7/45 he was awarded
a Bar to
his DFC at Buckingham
Palace from the King. He served in
RAF Intelligence during the Korean
War. His AJEX Jewish Chaplain card
mentions an article on him in “The
Jewish Chronicle” (noted as JC
henceforth) of 24/9/43. Cyril featured
on a Channel 4 TV programme in Jan
2004, “Spitfire Ace” and
in 2002 on a another Channel 4 Programme
on the Spitfire as weapon of WW2.
58063/46170
Pilot Officer, later Sqdn. Leader,
Ben Bardega
of 20 Cheyne Walk, NW4 (AJEX
Card) joined the RAF in February
1939, No 50 Squadron, DFM 14th Sept.
1940 (“The Times”), died
25th May 1958, buried
Golders Green. He is not included
in Wynn’s book.
581137
Sgt. Alfred James Baum (Air Ministry Roll)
was a Sergeant
Observer in 49 Squadron. He was killed
in action on 11th August
1940 and is buried at Reichswald,
grave 30-B-7. No more is known about
him but he is not mentioned in Morris
and an AJEX card has not been found.
However, his name is inscribed on
a memorial to Jewish personnel killed
in WW2 from the North East of England.
751790
Louis Lionel Benjamin
was
a Sergeant Observer in 53 Squadron
Coastal Command RAFVR (Air Ministry
Roll) and his AJEX card says
he volunteered on June 6th 1939
and was stationed at Hamble, Hants.
His wife was Elizabeth Betty and
lived at 170 Cotsbach Rd., Clapton,
London E5, formerly at 4, Cavendish
Mansions, Mill Lane, NW6. He is named
in Morris and was officially reported
missing killed in action, aged 22
years, son of Hyam and Bessie, on
31/8/40 by the RAF and in the Jewish
Chronicle on 28/3/41. The JC also
published a letter on 30/9/49 from
Arthur Levy about there being a cross
on his grave (plot LL – 2 -5)
and that this was being referred
to the War Graves Commission at Crosswijk,
Rotterdam, by the Jewish Chaplains.
123055/759128
Frank Samuel Day
was aka Deitchman b. Hackney 1914, was a Sgt. Observer in 248 Squadron and
came from Golders Green. He fought
throughout the campaign, was commissioned
in May 1942 but was killed in action
on July 24th 1942 with
86 Squadron, aged 28 years en route to Malta in a Beaufort Torpedo Bomber with 3 other crew. He was
son of Nathaniel and Rika and is
buried at St Illogan churchyard,
Cornwall, Row 1, grave 20.
His name is in Morris but there is
no AJEX card for him.
79166
John Lionel De Keyser (Air Ministry
Roll)
was a Pilot Officer with
206 Squadron RAFVR, Coastal Command.
His AJEX card says he was a former
member of Stepney Jewish Boys club
and his name occurs in Morris. He
was killed in action 15/10/40 age
25 years and is inscribed on the
Runnymede memorial on panel 8. He
was the son of William and Asneth
of Johannesburg, South Africa. His
death was announced in “The
Stepnian” club journal in August
1941 and in the JC of 13/2/40.
81887
P. Off. Emil Fechtner Czech 310 Sqdn.
born
16/9/1916 – escaped Czech Air
Force on March 15th 1939,
joined the Foreign Legion in France.
Sept. 1939 he was seconded to French
l’Armee de l’Air and
later escaped to England after France
fell. He was posted to Duxford to
form the Czech 310 Sqdn. July 12th 1940.
Crashed in accident Aug 1st and
on 15th landed after a
collision at Upwood. On Aug 26th he
shot down a 110 and on 31st a
Do. 215 in Hurricane V3889, which
was damaged . On Sept 3rd he
shot down a 110 and the on 18th a
Do 215. Awarded DFC Oct. 1940. but
sadly was killed in a crash landing
at Duxford on Oct 29th 1940,
after a collision with P. Off. J
M Maly. Buried at Brookwood. Information
on Jewish background from web site math.fce.vutbr.cz/safarik/ACES1/ww2-commonwealth-jewish.html
42598 George Ernest Goodman
was Pilot Officer, later Flying Officer in No. 1 Squadron. He was born in Haifa, Israel on August 10, 1920
and his mother was Jewish Bida Lerner from the Israeli town of Zichron Yaacov.
Wynn says Goodman was British solely because he had a British passport
– like most born under the Mandate - but he was in fact an Israeli
“sabra” and the only Israeli in the Battle of Britain.
RAF Museum researcher John Edwards testifies to these facts in an
article in “London Jewish News” , 22/9/2000, by reporter
John Kaye . Furthermore
in Mason’s book on page 506, Goodman is described as “Palestinian”, in
another as “Israeli”, and yet another also as Israeli.
The author also has in his possession an official copy of Goodman’s
birth certificate, all in Hebrew, from the Haifa municipality in Israel,
now kept at the AJEX Musuem .
Educated
at Highgate school he was son of Sydney
and Bida Goodman, was in the OTC and
took a commission in the RAF in early
1939, joining his Hurricane Squadron
in France in March 1940, where he shared
a kill of an HE 111 and shot down another
later which had helped sink the SS Lancastria
off St Nazaire. Later, flying from Northolt
he shot down an Me109, shared in another,
then shot down an He 111 and then shared
a Do 17 and then shot down another 110.
On August 18th he was hit
in his Hurricane P3757 but managed to
land safely .On September
6th 1940 he shot down another
110 but was himself shot down , baling
out with an injury. His plane crashed
at Brownings Farm, Chiddingstone Causeway.
He later shared a Ju 88, damaged a Do
17 and was awarded the DFC on
26/11/40.
In
Nov. 1940 he flew the ferry route for
the Middle East with 73 Squadron and
stopped at Lagos where his parents were
working in the diplomatic service. He
saw his mother for the last time (his
father was away) and as the Squadron
later flew out, they did a roll over
the Goodman home and then were away.
In
February 1941 he shot down a CR42 in
the Western Desert, and a 110 at Tobruk,
but he was shot down but crash landed
behind the British lines. He then shared
an Hs 126, destroyed a Ju 87 and shared
another, all over Tobruk. In April he
took leave in Haifa, Israel, with his
two sisters, but on June 14th 1941
he was shot down and killed by flak over
Gazala. He is buried in Knightsbridge
cemetery, Acroma, Libya, grave 10.C.21 .
135476
Maurice Venning Goodman
was
a Sgt. Air Gunner with 604 Squadron,
later Flt. Lt., and born in Hendon
on 13/4/20. Educated at King’s
School Colindale, he joined the AAF
and was called up at outbreak of war.
He served on air operations throughout
the Battle of Britain and then in 1942
on special operations over Germany,
severely damaging a 110. He then served
on special operations in North Africa
and Italy and was awarded the DFC on
12.11.43. He died in 1988. His Jewish
Chaplain card mentions an article on
him in “The Jewish Chronicle” on
12/11/43.
81945
P. Off. Vilem Goth Czech 310 and
501 Sqdns.
born 22/4/1915
and joined 310 Sqdn. at Duxford 10/7/1940.
On Sept 7th he shot down
two 110’s over Southend but
his Hurricane V6643 was damaged,
forcing him to land at Whitmans Farm,
Purleigh. Joined 501 Sqdn. at Kenley
in Oct 1940 and sadly was killed
Oct 25th when he collided
with P. O. K W Mackenzie during combat
over Tenterden, crashing in Hurricane
2903 in Bridgehurst Wood, Marden.
He is buried at Sittingbourne and
Milton Cemetery, Kent. Information
on Jewish background from same web
site as Fechtner (above)
78684
Eric Stewart Issacson Hallows (Air
Ministry Roll)
was a pilot Officer
in 99 Squadron Bomber Command. His
AJEX card says he was first with
79 Squadron and had been stationed
at Harwell, Didcot and Mildenhall.
He was husband of Mrs M Hallows,
of Russley, Wood Ditton Rd., Newmarket.
He was killed in action on 30/10/40
and buried at Willesden Jewish cemetery
in London in grave FX-13-554. His
AJEX card states that the JC was
notified on 1/11/40, published notification
of his death on 8/11/40 and that
he was buried on 4/11/40, the funeral
being officiated by Rev. Gollomb,
HCF. He is named in Morris’s
book.
37970
Eustace “Gus” Holden
was
a Flt. Lt./Pilot, later Wing
Commander with 501 Squadron. Born
in Doncaster on 28/12/12, he was
commissioned in the RAF in 1936.
In May 1940 in France he shot down
a Ju 88, Do 7 and an He 111. Later
from Croydon he damaged a Do 17 but
was himself wounded later on July
22nd. He was awarded the DFC on
16/8/40. In Sept./Oct he shot down
two 109’s, a 110, 2 more 109’s,
damaged a Ju 88 and damaged two more
109’s. As C/O of 501 Squadron,
he took them to West Africa in June
1941 and then became a Staff Officer
(Fighter Training) at the Air Ministry.
In 1944 he was posted to HQ Far East,
Kandy, staying in the RAF until 1964.
His Jewish Chaplain card mentions
his being based at Tokoradi, and
seeing Senior Jewish Chaplain Rabbi
Brodie .
90705
Kenneth Holden
(older
brother of Eustace) was a Flying
Off./Pilot, later Wing Commander
with 616 Squadron and with Eustace
were the only Jewish brothers who
flew in the Battle. He joined the
AAF in 1939 and was called up at
outbreak of war. On May 28th /June
1st 1940 over Dunkirk he shot down
three 109’s and in Sept. damaged
two more and shot down another. In
May 1941 he was made Squadron Leader
and later shot down three more 109’s,
damaged two more and shared another.
Awarded the DFC on
15/7/41, he later moved to Staff
HQ of 12 Group. Retired from the
RAF in 1950, he died in 1991. No
Jewish Chaplain card seems to have
been written for him.
748158
Lewis Reginald Isaac
was
a Sgt. Pilot with 64 Squadron , and
from Llanelli, South Wales, son of
James and Blodwen. He joined the
RAFVR in May 1939 and fought throughout
the Battle. Sadly, he failed to return
from a Channel sortie in his Spitfire
L1029 after a surprise attack on
his airfield , on Aug. 5th 1940.
He had been shot down by an ME 109
off Folkestone at 0850. He was 24
years old. He is remembered at Runnymede,
Panel 15. His loss is mentioned in
the Jewish Chronicle on April 25th 1941,
but no Jewish chaplain card appears
to exist although he is in Morris’s
book (see above).
78685
Henry “Jake” Jacobs
was a Pilot Officer/Air Gunner
and later Squadron Leader with 219
and 600 Squadron. He was born on
15/4/07 in Gt. Yarmouth. In Sept.
1940 he shot down a Ju 88. In 1942
he shot down two Ju88’s and
damaged another. He was awarded the DFC on
9.10.42 (appearing in the JC 16.10.42).
In 1943 shot down three 110’s
, a Do 217, a 110 and damaged a Ju
88. He was awarded a Bar to
his DFC on 5.11.43 (announced
in the JC 26/11/43) and AFC on
the 3.4.45. He retired from the RAF
in 1958 and died in 1978. His Jewish
Chaplain card states his parents
were Mr and Mrs J Jacobs of The Cottage,
Hingham, Norfolk and that he met
several Jewish Chaplains in his post
war career. His DFC citation says “for
valuable service rendered as chief
signals instructor of 264 Squadron,
Duxford ; has destroyed two enemy
aircraft – a source of inspiration
to his men”. The citation for
his bar says “has helped destroy
six enemy aircraft; he is a model
of efficiency”.
1050704
Norman Jacobson
was an AC2 Radio
Operator with 29 Squadron and from
Grimsby. He joined the RAF in June
1940 and was in an aircraft which
shot down an He 111 in August. But
on Aug 25th his Blenheim
was shot down near Wainfleet and
the crew were all killed. Jacobson
was just 18 years old - the youngest
Battle of Britain casualty - and although
his body was recovered by a trawler
(“Alfredian” ) near the
Inner Dowsing, he was buried at sea
on Aug. 27 and his name is engraved
on the Runnymede memorial panel 27.
He was the son of Alfred and Olive
Jacobson.
85010
Arthur Harold Evans Kahn
was
a Pilot Officer, later Flt. Lt. Observer,
with 248 Squadron. Born in Sutton, Surrey,
he joined the RAFVR in May 1939 and fought
throughout the Battle. He was killed
in action on June 15th 1944
with 172 Squadron, aged 25 years, son
of Joseph and Mai, husband of Helen Margaret.
His name is inscribed on the Runnymede
memorial panel 202 and he is in Morris’s
book (see above).
787527
Sgt. Pilot Oldrich Kestler Czech
111 Sqdn.
Born
Cizice 18/3/1920, joined 111 at Dyce
19/10/1940. Joined 605 Sqdn. and
7/4/1941 he collided in Hurrican
Z318, with Spitfire P 8315 (Sgt Martinec,
Czech) and both were killed. Awarded
Czech Military Cross – buried
Market Drayton , Shropshire. Jewish
background information from same
web site as Fechtner (above).
780685 Zygmunt
“Joe” Klein
was a Sgt.
Pilot with Polish 234 and 152 Squadrons . He was born on 24.8.18,
born Koronowo, joined PAF in 1936, to 142 Sqdn, and flew against the
Luftwaffe in Poland in 1939-40, escaping via France to Britain. He
also joined the RAF in Feb. 1940. Joined 234 Sqdn. at St Eval 6/8/40
- was shot down but bailed out on August 15, 1940, and later went
to Warmwell with 152 Sqdn. He shot down one 109 and shared a 110 and
damaged another 110. He crash landed in Spitfire P9427 out of fuel
near Torquay on Nov. 26th 1940. In a Channel 4 TV Programme,
“Spitfire Ace” , televised on 19/1/04, LAC Joe Roddis
described how his groundcrew most admired the Polish flyers as they
were determined to kill Germans, not just shoot down aircraft; their
country was occupied and they hated the enemy with a vengeance. He
named Klein as one of the bravest and described how on one very foggy
day they were all ordered to be grounded. But Klein heard a German
aircraft patrolling over the aerodrome and against orders took off
and brought it down in very dangerous flying conditions. He was declared
Missing on Nov.28th, believed killed in action in his Spitfire
in the Isle of Wight area, by 109’s . His name is inscribed
on the Polish Air Force memorial at Northolt. Awarded Polish Cross
of Valour (KW) and Bar.
118438/903367/902927
Lennert Axel/Aexel Komaroff
was Sgt. air gunner with
141 Squadron flying Defiants and
Beaufighters. With FO I.H. Cosby
he shot down a Ju88 south of the
Isle of Wight on Aug. 25th 1941.
Flying throughout the Battle, he
was commissioned in March 1942 .
He was killed on Sept. 19th 1944
flying Mosquitoes with 29 Squadron,
aged 26 years. He was husband of
Helen Komaroff of Prestwick and is
buried at Bergen-op-Zoom, Holland
in grave 28.A.2 . He is named in
Morris’s book (see above) and
his AJEX card states that he had
previously been wounded in action.
77345/746721
Marcus Kramer
was a Pilot Officer with
600 Squadron. A pharmacist from Thorpe
Bay Essex, he was born in Bermondsey
in 1911 and active in the local Jewish
community , son of Mr and Mrs Emmanuel
Kramer of 3, Marine Parade, Southend-on-Sea . He joined
the RAFVR in March 1939, and was
commissioned in Feb. 1940. On May
10th 1940 he flew as gunner
with PO R C Haine with 6 Blenheims
on an attack on Rotterdam (Waalhaven)
aerodrome, just captured by German
paratroops that morning. After the
attack they were shot down by 110’s
but he evaded capture and was evacuated
with his crew by the RN. He was awarded
the DFC on 9.7.40 (see
JC reference May 15th 1942
page 3, and his AJEX card), but he
was killed in action on 21/5/41 with
29 Squadron, aged 29 years. His name
is on the Runnymede memorial Panel
29. His AJEX card states that the
Jewish Chaplains wrote to the father
who replied that “his plane
was seen to crash into the River
Severn near Chepstow and his tunic
was washed up almost immediately” and
is therefore believed to be dead.
Also that the “Times” reported
his death on the 31/12/41.
83269/54454
Emanuel Barnett Lyons
was Pilot Officer/Flt.
Lt. with 65 Squadron and born in
London in 1918. He joined the RAFVR
in June 1939, from Magdalene College
Cambridge , fighting
throughout the Battle. He was later
posted to North Africa in support
of 1st Army. In 1944 he
fought in many air battles in Europe,
being wounded in April 1945. He was
awarded the DFC on
8.5.45 and the Netherlands
Flying Cross on 21.4.47 for
gallantry when some of his squadron
included Dutch pilots. His AJEX card
shows he was the son of Mrs R Lyons,
c/o E Barnett and Co., 27-83 Middlesex
St., London E1 and 38, South Lodge,
Circus Rd, NW8 . There were articles
about him in the JC of 10/3/45 and
9/6/47. He died in 1992.
81621
Andrew “Andy” B. Mamedoff
was a Pilot Officer from
the USA and with 609 Squadron. An
American researcher has confirmed
with AJEX that he was Jewish , son of
Natalie and husband of Alys nee Craven
of London. He was born on 24.8.12,
and brought up in Thompson, Connecticut.
He performed in air shows and at
outbreak of war he tried to fight
with the Finnish Air Force and later
the French Air Force but failed and
had to stowaway to the UK where he
was given an Emergency Commission
in the RAF and sent to a Spitfire
squadron on Aug. 8th 1940
with two other Americans he had met
in France. They became the first
three members of 71 Eagle Squadron,
USA Volunteers, fighting throughout
the Battle. On a flight to a posting
to Northen Ireland on 8.10.41, he
failed to arrive and his body was
later recovered for burial at Brookwood
cemetery, grave 21.A.7.
39675
William “Bill” Henry
Nelson
was
Flying Officer with 24 Squadron and
born in Montreal, Canada on 2.4.17,
son of Henry and Sarafina Nelson
of 4885 Cote St, Catherine Rd. He
was educated at Baron Byng High and
Strathcona Academy and joined the
RAF in 1937 after working his way
to England. On Sept. 8/9th 1939
he took part as Captain of a bomber
in the RAF’s earliest operation,
with 8 Whitley’s dropping leaflets
in NW Germany. After other operations
he also took part in raids on Sylt
and over Dunkirk during the evacuation.
He was awarded the DFC by
the King at Buckingham Palace on
4.6.40, and was the first Canadian
Jew decorated in WW2 . His citation
read “Nelson carried out many
flights over enemy territory, always
showing the greatest determination
and courage. After one attack on
Stavanger, Norway, he encountered
a balloon barrage and sent a report
to base HQ in time to warn following
aircraft”.
He
wrote home that “ I thank God that
I shall be able to help to destroy the
regime that persecutes the Jews…..”
Volunteering
for Fighter Command and returning before
his leave expired, he flew Spitfires
from Hornchurch , shooting down a 109,
110 and damaging another 110 on Aug.
11th 1940 when he took on
six 109’s singehanded ; damaging
a Do 17 on the 13th and destroying
three more 109’s on Oct. 17th,
27th and 29th.
He was killed on 1.11.40 by a 109 attack
over Dover in Spitfire P7312 at 1400
hrs. and crashed into the Channel. He
was listed as missing on the 52nd RAF
casualty list on Nov 14th but
officially presumed killed on May 26th 1941.
He was 23 years old, left a wife (Marjorie
Isobel) and young son and his name is
inscribed on the Runnymede memorial,
panel 4. He has an AJEX Chaplain card.
42076
Reginald Tony Pareezer (Air
Ministry Roll)
was Pilot Officer
with 204 Squadron Coastal Command
and killed on 21/7/40 aged 21 years.
He was son of Reginald and Florence
of Thorpe, Norfolk and is remembered
at Runnymede on panel 9. He is named
in Morris, but no AJEX Chaplain card
was found.
41735
Frederick Hyam/Hyman Posener
was Pilot Officer
with 152 Squadron , and joined the
RAF from South Africa in Dec. 1938
fighting through the Battle and was
wounded in action . He was
shot down, aged 23 years, in his
Spitfire K9880 at 1635 hrs. on July
20th 1940 off Swanage
by Luftwaffe Oberlt. Homuth. His
name is inscribed on the Runnymede
memorial, Panel 9. RAF Innsworth
records show he was Jewish and his
death is announced in the JC of 18/4/41.
His AJEX card says he was son of
J. Posener, POB 504, East London,
South Africa.
40138/40404
Roderick Malachi Seaburne Rayner
was Flying Officer/Wing
Commander with 87 Squadron. He was
born on 6/1/18, joined the RAF in
1937 and was in France on the outbreak
of war. During the Battle he shot
down a 110, 109, Do 17, another 110
and 109 and shared an He 111 . Over
the UK he shot down two other 110’s
but on Dec 23rd 1940 had
to bale out of his Hurricane in bad
weather near Brize Norton. Was awarded
a DFC on 11.2.41, though
his AJEX card says it was gazetted
30.7.43. He damaged another unidentified
German aircraft in the Gloucester
area in April 1941. He died in 1982.
39683
Reginald Frank Rimmer
was
a FO of 229 Squadron and son of a
WW1 pilot. The family were living
in Wirral at the time of outbreak
of war. He joined the RAF in 1937
and on June 2nd 1940 over
Dunkirk damaged a He 111, later destroying
a Do17 and sharing an He 111. He
was shot down in his Hurricane V6782 “T” at
1530 hrs. and killed by 109’s
on Sept. 27th 1940 over
Franchise Manor Farm, Burwash aged
21 years and is buried at Hoylake
Grange , Cheshire (grave D79) and
is remembered on a plaque at the
farm where he crashed. He was son
of Launcelot and Cecilia of Hoylake.
He is named in Morris’s book
but there is no AJEX card for him.
A photo of his grave shows a cross
but this was a common error for many
Jewish servicemen killed in both
World Wars where incorrect information
was supplied about religious affiliation .
41209
Geoffrey Louis Ritcher
was
a Flying Officer/Squadron Leader
with 234 Squadron. He joined the
RAF in July 1938, fought throughout
the Battle and shot down a Do 17
in France. His AJEX card says he
graduated from No 1 Air Observer’s
School, North Coates, Grimsby.
41472
Jack Rose
was a Flying Officer/
Wing Commander with No. 3, 32 and
232 Squadrons. He was born in London
on 18/1/17, attended Shooters Hill
School, University at UCL (studying
Science) and joined the RAF in 1938.
From Biggin Hill he was sent to France
and shot down three enemy aircraft
in May 1940. He was shot down in
his Hurricane V6547 at 1900 hrs.
on August 25th by a 109
over the Channel and rescued . He
was awarded the DFC on
9.10.42 and commanded 113 Squadron
in Burma from Nov. 1944. He was further
awarded the MBE and CGM in
1946. His DFC citation says on his
AJEX card “ He has been on
operational flying since Sept. 1939.
During May 1940 whilst serving with
fighters over France, he destroyed
three enemy aircraft. Posted to his
present unit, he has led squadrons
in 15 sweeps over France. He has
displayed courage and devotion to
duty and rendered valuable assistance
to allied wing commanders”.
900030
Maurice Rose
was
a Sergeant (Air Ministry Roll)
in 102 Squadron RAFVR and was killed
in action on 29/10/40. He is in Morris’s
book and is remembered at Runnymede
on Panel 19. His AJEX card says he
was first in Hut 756, B squad, No
2 Wing, No 2 School, Yatesbury, and
then at No 7 Bombing and Gunnery
School, Porthcawl. His father was
J Rose of 46, First Avenue, Selby
Park, Birmingham.
84970
Francis Herbert Schumer
was a Pilot Officer
with 600 Squadron. He was
educated at Giggleswick School and
Worcester College, Oxford and a member
of the University Air Squadron. He
joined the RAFVR in June 1939 as
trainee 754291 and Commissioned in
Sept. 1940. He crash landed in a
Blenheim on Sept. 12th,
fought throughout the Battle and
was killed in action on 12/7/41 aged
22 years. He was cremated at Golders
Green cemetery. His AJEX card gives
his mother as Mrs J Schumer, 107,
Hodford Rd., NW11 and his death was
notified to the JC on July 18th ,
1941.
37870
Lionel Harold Schwind
was
Pilot Officer with 257, 43 and 213
Squadrons. He joined the RAF in 1936,
was then posted to Iraq but was flying
Hurricanes throughout the Battle
of Britain. He was shot down and
killed over Gatwick on 27/9/40 in
Hurricane N2401 “O” at
0925 hrs. crashing on Wildemesse
golf course, Seal, near Sevenoaks,
aged 27 years – the same day
as Rimmer. He was son of Lionel and
Florence nee Dayton of Crowborough,
Sussex and husband of Georgina nee
Trueman. He is buried at Crowborough
cemetery, Sussex, grave 1723. His
brother 581353 Sgt. Gordon Louis
Schwind RAF, was killed aged 21 on
May 26th 1940 and is buried at Comines-Warneton,
Hainaut, Belgium . No AJEX
card was found for Lionel or Gordon,
but Gordon’s name was submitted
to Henry Morris’s second book, “The
Addendum”.
78257
Herbert Ronald Sharman
was
Pilot Officer/Squadron Leader with
248 Squadron. Born in Wood Green,
London on 22.10.07 he was educated
at Trinity County School. He joined
the RAFVR in 1939, was commissioned
in March 1940 and fought throughout
the Battle. He then trained in Canada
and returned to the UK in 1943 as
an instructor in navigation. With
297 Squadron he flew Whiteley’s
inserting agents into occupied Europe,
and then flew VIP’s to summit
meetings in Casablanca, Tehran and
Yalta. From March 1944 he undertook
other VIP flights in the Far East
and was awarded the AFC on
7.9.45. He has an AJEX Jewish Chaplain
card.
85241
Leslie Mark Sharp
was
Pilot Officer with 111 Squadron, son
of Mr and Mrs M Sharp of 53 Adelaide
Park, Belfast. He joined the RAFVR in
Aug. 1939 as trainee 758214. Commissioned
on Sept. 7th 1940, he flew
Hurricanes with 96 and 111 Squadrons.
Fighting through the Battle he took off
on the night of 28/12/40 and crashed
suddenly into the sea one mile offshore.
He is buried at Carnmoney Jewish cemetery,
Co. Antrim. He has an AJEX card and his
photo and announcement of his death are
in the JC of 10/1/41 .
563391
William Gerald Silver
was
Sgt. Pilot with 152 Squadron and
educated at Portsmouth Technical
school. He joined the RAF in 1929,
flying Spitfires throughout the Battle.
On Sept. 25th 1940 he
did not return from a dogfight over
the Portsmouth area in Spitfire P9463
at 1115 hrs., and is buried at Milton
Rd cemetery, Portsmouth, Plot U,
Row 23a, Grave 13. He was 27 years
old .
79731/742006
Neville David Solomon
was Pilot Officer with 29
and 17 Squadrons and joined the RAFVR
in Sept. 1938. He was Commissioned
in Sept. 1939. Flying Blenheims,
he converted to Hurricanes flying
both types throughout the Battle.
He was reported missing Aug. 18th in
Hurricane L1921 at 1.05pm after a dogfight
with 109’s off Dover and had
crashed into the sea. The incident
is described in “The Hardest
Day” . He is buried
at Pihen-les-Guines, Calais, France,
Row A, Grave 4. He was son of Lt
Col. Archibald Baron Solomon and
Ethel Betsy of 69 Woodbourne Rd.,
Edgbaston, Birmingham and 3, Livery
St., Birmingham. His Jewish Chaplain
card states that when reported missing
in action, condolences letters were
sent to his family on 23/9/40 and
again on 10/2/41, and it was reported
in “The JC” on 29/9/40
(the same day as Wilk - see below)
as well as mentioned in “The
Times”. The Jewish Chaplaincy
continued correspondence with the
father until June 1948. A photo of
him is in the JC of 3/5/40, noting
his serving in the RAF.
749478
Aubrey H. Spiers
was Sgt.
Wireless Op./Air Gunner/W. Officer with
236 Squadron and had joined the RAFVR
in May 1939. Heflew 21 sorties throughout
the Battle. No further information was
found on his AJEX card. He died in 1988.
37306
Robert Roland Stanford Tuck
was known as “Lucky Tuck” and was Flt.
Lt/Wing Commander with 92 and 257
Squadrons. He was born in Catford
on 1.7.16, son of Capt. Stanley Lewis
Tuck (Capt. in Royal West Surreys,
in WW1 ) and Ethel Clara , and educated
at St Dunstan’s College, Reading.
He was at sea for two years as a
Cadet and then joined the RAF in
1935. Whilst training at Grantham,
he was almost killed in a mid air
collision caused by turbulence and he had
to bale out severely scarring his
face. At Duxford in 1938 he became
one of the RAF’s first Spitfire
qualified pilots.
As a
Flight Commander, over Dunkirk on May
23rd 1940, in his Spitfire,
he shot down three 110’s and a
109, on the 24th two Do 17’s,
on the 25th shared a Do 17,
on June 2nd a 109 and He 111,
and two 109’s damaged. He was wounded
in this incident. His Squadron Leader
at this time was Roger Bushell, of “Great
Escape” fame and whom he later
met again at Sagan camp after capture.
When Bushell was shot down over Dunkirk,
Tuck took over as Squadron Leader. Tuck
was awarded the DFC on
the 11.6.40 from the King at a special
ceremony at Hornchurch, for “initiative
and personal example over Dunkirk”.
He
continued shooting the enemy out of the
sky; shared a Do 17 on July 8th,
damaged a Ju 88 on the 25th,
shared a Ju 88 on Aug. 13th,
destroyed two Ju 88’s on the 14th and
two on the 18th- but he was
shot down that day, baling out with an
injury over Horsmonden ( his Spitfire
crashing at Tuck’s Cottages, Park
Farm) on the estate of Lord Cornwallis – who
then invited him to tea!
On
Aug 25th he shot down another
Do 17 but his plane was shot up and he
glided 15 miles to the coast with a dead
engine off St Gowan’s Head and
crash landed. On Sept. 11th ,
Commanding 257 Squadron, he shot down
a 110 and 109, on the 23rd a
109, Oct. 4th a Ju 88, on
the 12th a 109, on the 25th a
109 and two damaged and on the 28th two
more 109’s!! He was awarded a Bar
to the DFC on 25.10.40 , The
Times writing that, “In the
face of constant death he preserved a
lightness of heart which was not simply
bravura but allied to precise and ruthlessly
applied technical skill”.
On
Dec. 19th , now flying Hurricanes,
he shot down another Do 17, on the 12th a
109, on the 29th a Do 17.
He was awarded the DSO on
7.1.41 “for leading 257 Squadron
with great success….his outstanding
leadership, courage and skill have been
reflected in its high morale and efficiency”.
The King awarded the DSO and announced
the 2nd bar to Tuck on 28/1/41
and at the same ceremony awarded the
DFC to his good friend Brian van Mentz
(see below) – a unique occasion
for two Jewish RAF officers to be decorated
together !
He
continued; March 2nd and 19th 1941
two more Do 17’s, April 9th a
Ju 88, 27th damaged a Ju 88,
and May 11th shot down two
more Ju 88’s. Awarded a Second
Bar to DFC on 11.4.41 “for
conspicuous gallantry and initiative
in searching for and attacking enemy
raiders, often in adverse weather conditions” – he
was only the second RAF pilot to win
such a distinction.
On
June 21st he destroyed two
109’s and damaged another but was
himself wounded and shot down in the
Channel but picked up in his dinghy by
a Gravesend coal barge after two hours.
As Wing Leader at Duxford commanding
three squadrons, he shot down three more
109’s. He was then sent as a Liaison
Officer to the USA with other aces, including “Sailor” Malan,
and then returned to Biggin Hill as a
Wing Leader. On Jan. 28th 1942
he was shot down by flak on low level
strafing attack outside Boulogne and
made a POW. He was interviewed by Adolf
Galland and after the war – ironically
for a Jewish pilot – made an Honorary
member of Galland’s old German
Squadron !
In
various camps, he helped plan the “Great
Escape” from Sagan but was moved
before the breakout . He finally
escaped on Feb. 1st 1945 with
Flt. Lt. Kustrzynski and met up with
the Russians and spent two weeks fighting
with them. They then made their way to
the British Embassy in Moscow and were
sent to Southampton by ship via Odessa.
Tuck was awarded the USA DFC on
14.6.46.
Tuck
was shot down 4 times, collided twice,
was wounded twice, baled out, crash landed
and dunked in the Channel ! The Official
History of the RAF Vol. 1, states “They
had that restless spirit of aggression,
that passion to be at grips with the
enemy, which is the hallmark of the very
finest troops. Some – like Bader,
Malan and Stanford Tuck – were
so fiercely possessed of this demon,
and of the skill to survive the danger
into which it drew them, that their names
were quickly added to the immortal company
of Ball, Bishop, Mannock and McCudden” .
Tuck
is probably the most highly decorated
Jewish WW2 pilot after Louis Aarons,
VC, DFM. He is credited with 30 kills
- one not added till 1982 making
him the eighth ranking ace of the RAF
with more victories than any other British pilot . His portrait
hangs at Bentley Priory RAF base at Stanmore – Fighter
Command HQ in WW2 - alongside many other
Battle of Britain pilots. He died aged
70 years on 5.5.87. His Jewish Chaplain
card mentions an article on him in the
JC in Jan. 1941. He was also a great
friend of Jewish Fighter Pilot Ronnie
Austin Jarvis (killed in 1941) and their
visit to the home, for example, of the
Jewish Barnato family is well documented .
70826
Brian van Mentz
was Flying
Officer with 222 Squadron. He was
born in Johannesburg, South Africa
in 1916, son of Sidney and Rosine
and nephew of Samuel Mence of Burghclere,
Hants. He was Commissioned in the
South African RAF Reserve in 1937
and the RAF in 1938. In France he
shot down a Ju 88 on May 14th 1940,
Ju 87 and He 126 on the 15th,
damaged two 109’s on the 16th.
From Hornchurch he shot down a 109
on 31st Aug., a 110 and
damaged another on Sept. 3rd,
a 109 and shared a Do 17 on Sept.
7th, a Ju 88 and damaged
a 109 on the 11th, damaged
a Ju 88 on the 15th, shot
down a 109 on the 23rd,
and damaged a 110 on Oct 12th.
He was awarded the DFC on
25.10.40. The JC report says in November
, “This officer led his section
with great skill and courage, and
showed great determination in pressing
home his attacks against large enemy
formations. He has been engaged in
flying operations against the enemy
since the outbreak of war” .
It was also reported in the JC on
17/1/41.
On
Oct. 30th he damaged a 109
and on Nov 30th shot down
a Do 17. He was decorated by the King
at Bircham Newton on 28.1.41, together
with Tuck (see above). On Feb. 2nd he
shot down a Ju 88 , damaged an He 111
and on March 18th shared a
Do 17.
Having
flown 75 sorties , he was
killed on April 26th 1941
aged 24 years when a bomb hit the Ferry
Inn pub, Coltishall, not half an hour
after Robert Tuck had left him to go
to Norwich for a drive . He is
buried at Brookwood cemetery, Woking,
Grave 25.A.9 . The JC
of 17/1/41 says he was the son of Major
van Mentz, adjudant of the Witwatersrand
Rifles, killed in action in WW1.
115547/754595
Jack Weber
was Sgt. Pilot/Flt. Lt. with
No. 1 and 145 Squadrons and joined
the RAFVR in July 1939. He was born in Hove on October 12, 1917. Fighting
from Tangmere throughout the Battle,
he was shot down in his Hurricane
by an ME 109 in the afternoon - but
survived - over the Isle of Wight
on Nov 6th 1940. Commissioned
in 1942 he was Mentioned in
Despatches whilst fighting
in the Middle East. Whilst protecting
Kittyhawk bombers on July 15th he
was shot down and again wounded.
His Jewish Chaplain
card states that his father was Mr
Joseph Weber of 521 Finchley Rd., NW3
and that he was seen by several Chaplains.
Jack came from a family of shoe manufacturer, Weber & Phillips Footwear based in Tottenham. He was a member of the North London Reform Synagogue. After moving to Brentwood, Essex, he became a District councillor and was Chair of the Council and Chair of the Planning Committee.
He died in Brockenhurst, Hampshire on 5th May 1988 aged 70.
76932/78451
Jack Wilk (Air
Ministry Roll)
was a Pilot Officer/Air
Gunner with 149 Squadron RAFVR, Bomber
Command . His name is in Morris and
his AJEX card says he was born in
1904 in South Africa and volunteered
for the RAF on 30/12/39. He was at
No 1 Air Armament School, Manby,
Lincolnshire and then No. 11 O.T.U.
at Bassingbourn. He was Killed in
Action on 17/8/40 aged 36 years son
of Abraham and Fairie Wilk nee Mindelsohn
and was a Barrister (MA, Ll.B), living
at 73, Westfield Road, Birmingham.
His death was announced in the Jewish
Chronicle on 27/9/40 and an obituary
with photograph says he was a Cambridge
graduate who had served in the Civil
Air Guard pre war and was very active
in the Birmingham Jewish Community.
A second obituary appeared on 4/10/40.
He is buried at Durnbach, Germany,
grave 6-H-6.
755989
Israel Winberg
was
a Sergeant with 110 Squadron Bomber
Command RAFVR (Air Ministry Roll)
and is listed by Morris. His AJEX
card says he volunteered 5/11/39
and was at Training School 32 in
West Hartlepool, followed by Prestwick,
Bicester and Wattisham. He was son
of Morris and Anna Winburn aka Winberg
of 11 The Oakes West, Sunderland
and he was killed in action 24/7/40
aged 28 years and his name is inscribed
at Runnymede, panel 21. It was reported
in “The Times” 26/3/41
and the Jewish Chronicle on 13/8/40
and 4/4/41.
749523
Ian Alexander Zamek
was
a Sergeant with 58 Squadron RAFVR
Bomber Command (Air Ministry Roll). He
is named in Morris and his AJEX card
says he volunteered in April 1939
and was at London No.2 Centre and
later at Abingdon.
He
was son of Mr A Zamek, 16, Pendennis,
Derby Rd., Bournemouth. He was reported
as missing, killed in action by the RAF,
2/10/40 but deemed officially kia on
3/10/40 aged 22 years. This was notified
to the Jewish Chronicle on 18/10/40 and
again on 28/2/41. He is buried in Berlin
CWGC cemetery, grave 7-K-1to4. His brother
Norman Henry was also kia in the RAF
in 1942 (see note 31).
Probables
As well
as the above men, Wynn’s book reveals
others who have Jewish names, but whose
records show them as enlisted as other
denominations. This is especially true
of Polish and Czech pilots – for
reasons given in the introduction to
this article. As I cannot prove religious
affiliation, I give below only brief
details which the reader may follow up
on some of the “probably Jewish” pilots
of the Battle.
76568
Pilot Officer Jack Henry Bachman – 145
Squdn. kia 9/4/43 in Burma
81884
Pilot Officer/Sqdn. Ldr. Vaclav
Bergman – 310 Squdn; Czech; DFC,
MiD.
111486
Pilot Officer Derrick C Deuntzer
- 79/247 Squdns.
P1296
Pilot Officer Franciszek Jastrzebski – 302
Squdn; Polish; KIA, VM, KW with
3 bars, Cr de G.
745292
Sgt. Pilot Stephen Austin Levenson – British
, 611 Squdn.;KIA
76728
Flt. Lt. Jan Piotr Pfeiffer – Polish,
32/257 Squdns. – KIA
78256
Pilot Officer Edward C. Schollar – 248
Squdn.
84299
Flg. Officer David Stein -
British 263 Squdn. – KIA
There
are many others.
Furthermore,
in Henry Morris’s book four Polish
Jewish pilots are listed as having fought
in the Battle but are not in Wynn’s
book –
Navig.
Ryzrad Bychowski – killed
when plane crashed on landing.
Navig.
Zygmunt Glass – kia
over Holland 1943
Navig.
Rubin Lipszyc – kia
on last day of the war when in action
over Holland
Navig.
Eljasz Posner – kia
over the Channel 1942.
Conclusion
This
study is a tribute to the Jewish pilots
and aircrew who served and those who
died during the Battle of Britain, a
momentous struggle that has become almost
mythical in its re-telling in many books
and films. For those historians with
the drive, patience and determination,
similar stories can be told of the Jewish
contribution for all the epic battles
of World War Two – on land, sea
and in the air. Let it never be forgotten.
Summary
of WW2 Awards to Jewish Battle of
Britain Aircrew
DSO – 1
DFC
- 12
DFC
and Bar – 2 (2)
DFC
and Two Bars – 1 (2)
DFM
- 1
AFC – 2
AFM – 1
Czech
MC - 1
Netherlands
DFC – 1
Polish KW and Bar –3
USA DFC – 1
MBE – 1
CGM – 1
MiD
- 2
Acknowledgements
AJEX
Jewish Military Museum, London
Staff
of the Imperial War Museum Library, Lambeth
Staff
of the Tower Hamlets History Library,
Stepney
Staff
at RAF Innsworth, Gloucester.
Sources: Martin Sugerman, Reprinted with Permission. Martin Sugarman is an Archivist with the British Association of Jewish Ex-Servicemen and Women - AJEX - Jewish Military Museum, London
[1] Kenneth G Wynn, Men of
the Battle of Britain (London 1999) pp.i-x
[2] In a Jewish Chronicle article (22/11/96) researcher and founder of the Battle of Britain Society, Bill Bond, alleges 100 Jewish airmen fought in the Battle and some of those are buried at Hoop Lane Jewish cemetery in Golders Green.
[4] RAF Personnel Records in Gloucester
[5] “We Will Remember Them” Brassey’s 1989, London and “The Addendum” AJEX, 1994, London.
[6] These profiles are taken mainly from Wynn, with further information added where indicated
[7] See website on Bamberger, “RAF Aces”
[8] “Men of the Battleof Britain” Supplementary Vol., KG Wynn, Gliddon Books 1992, page 62
[9] AJEX Battle of Britain file, AJEX Museum.
[10] See Sources section above.
[11] “The Few” by P Kaplan and R Collier, Blandford, London, 1989 page 222.
[12] “RAF Personnel in the Battle of Britain”, MoD, Imperial War Museum, no date. In “The Battle of Britain” (R T Bickers, London, 1990) the RAF WW2 author, in this official 50th Anniversary book, decsribes Goodman as Palestinian on page 197; ditto in the Jubilee Anniversary book “Battle of Britain “ by Hough and Richards page 191.
[13] At time of writing in Feb. 2004, the Battle of Britain Society is debating whether or not to include Israel/Palestine on its list of participating nations on a planned Battle memorial to be erected in London - trying to argue that Goodman was British! But, this is a double standard as Britons born in Rhodesia (as was) will be counted as Rhodesians!
[14] “The Battle of Britain Then and Now”, W G Ramsay, London 1980, After the Battle Magazines, p 366 – this was the same day that Solomon (see below) was killed.
[15] The Israel Air Force (IAF) Bulletin of 1997 decribes Goodman as “our first Ace, born in Israel” (thanks to Moshe Dolev, IAF researcher, of Tel Mond, Israel, for this article sent to the author in 2003)
[17] There is an eye witness anecdote from Holden in “Scramble” N. Gelb, M Joseph 1986, p.165
[18] Jacobs wrote an unpublished autobiography about his life, “Jacobs Ladder”, mentioned in R Collier’s “Eagle Day”, Dutton Books, New York, , 1966, page 306 bibliography – unobtainable by the author.
[19] “Battle of Britain Then and Now” page 380
[20] No AJEX card was found for Jacobson but it is known that they are not 100% complete or accurate.
[21] No AJEX card found, as above.
[23] “Jewish Military Casualties in the Polish Armed Forces in WW2”, Benjamin Meirtchak, Vol. 2 page 118, Tel-Aviv 1995
[24] “Polish Wings in the West”, by B. Arct, Warsaw 1971 p. 88, spells his name anagramatically as “Kinel”, almost certainly to deliberately to disguise his Jewish sounding name; a typical act of anti-Semitism.
[25] Jewish Chronicle 12/7/40 front page
[26] AJEX Jewish Chaplain card
[27] See USA file at AJEX Museum
[28] “The Splendid Hundred” A Bishop, McGraw-Hill, Toronto 1994 p.154
[29] “Canadian Jews in WW2 – part 1”, Canadian Jewish Congress 1947, Montreal, page 29.
[30] “Among the Few – Canadian Airmen in the Battle of Britain” Air Historical Section, Air Ministry booklet 1948 page 22.
[31] AJEX card information
[32] Posener is also mentioned in the Roll of Honour of “South African Jews in WW2” page xii, South African Board of Deputies, Johannesburg, 1950.
[33] Files at the AJEX Museum testify to several other examples of this.
[34] They are one of 18 sets of Jewish brothers killed in WW2; I am grateful to Harold Pollins for providing this information in “Shemot” September 2001, Journal of the Jewish Genealogical Society of Great Britain .
[35] See “The Battle of Britain Then and Now” edited by W G Ramsay 1989, After the Battle Books, London, page 755 for a photograph of a special memorial to him at the crash site.
[36] No AJEX card as above and his religious affiliation is to be confirmed
[37] “Battle of Britain Then and Now” p 366
[38] “The Hardest Day” A Price, London, page 92
[39] From an interview by Bob Cunningham with Tuck in 1986 published in “Code One”, the journal of the General Dynamics Company, Fort Worth, USA.
[40] A book has been written about Tuck – “Fly for your Life” by Larry Forrester, London 1956/1990, describing Tuck’s life and exploits in great detail – see pages 24-26.
[43] See Forrester dust cover summary
[45] Quoted in Forrester, frontpiece.
[48] “Spreading My Wings”, Diana Barnato-Walker, London 1994, p.139
[49] “Go Straight Ahead – Diaries of the 222 Natal Squadron”, E Burton, Square One, London, 1996, Appendix 3 ; this book contains more detail on van Mentz pages 169-173.
[50] See Forrester p.254-5
[51] Van Mentz is also mentioned as von Mentz, in the Roll of Honour, “South African Jews in WW2” page xiii and page 177, South African Board of Deputies, Johannesburg 1950.
[52] “We Will Remember Them – an Addendum” AJEX, London 1994 page 52.
|